Heatwaves hurt the poor most: time for an EU plan

  • Posted on: 23 July 2019
  • By: Yamina SAHEB

Recurring heatwaves across Europe have been most devastating for the poor. New EU institutions have a mandate to make Europe’s energy transition a just one, but this can only be done if a European Marshall plan is implemented to fight climate change and protect the vulnerable.

In my op-ed "Keeping cool in a warming world is not a luxury for the rich” I forecasted that this summer we again have to show how the increased frequency and severity of heatwaves would affect Europe’s poorest.

The European Energy Poverty Index  (EEPI) tool is the instrument that allows us to assess the progress made by EU member states in alleviating energy poverty. Users can estimate the impact of each driver of energy poverty on countries’ scores by moving the cursor.

The EEPI was built to provide a holistic picture of energy poverty and to compensate for the lack of data on summer and transport energy poverty. The EEPI is composed of two sub-indicators: the European Domestic Energy Poverty sub-Index (EDEPI) and the European Transport Energy poverty sub-Index (ETEPI).

The EEPI is the first EU indicator that allows for cross-country comparisons of the progress made in alleviating both domestic energy poverty (summer and winter) and transport energy poverty (car constrained users and public transport users) combined or taken separately.

The EEPI provides new insights about energy poverty in Europe (see table). The transport and domestic energy poverty nexus shows that the cotries progressing well in alleviating domestic energy poverty are not necessarily those who are tackling transport energy poverty.

The EDEPI shows a clear divide between Northern/Western countries and Eastern/Southern-Eastern countries in alleviating domestic energy poverty. The former are better equipped to deal with winter energy poverty.
It is easier to design building regulations and technological solutions with a special focus on the cold season only, rather than on both cold and hot seasons. Further, they have the biggest economies of Europe, which allows them to provide financial support to their poorest citizens to compensate for the rise of energy prices.

The ETEPI shows that the low-reliance on private cars for daily trips in some Eastern/Southern-Eastern allows them to perform better than some Northern/Western countries in alleviating transport energy poverty.
Overall, the EEPI suggests greater consideration of the transport and domestic energy poverty nexus in policy design. Improving the EEPI scores requires a fundamental change in the design of housing, land-use and mobility policies to avoid the trade-off between affordable housing and car dependency.

Unfortunately, heatwaves, such as the one we are now experiencing and which are no longer an exception, exacerbate energy poverty. High temperatures will continue to have an increasing impact on everyone—with the poor suffering the most socially, economically and in terms of health. It is the poor who disproportionally live in places where public transport is not available.

They are forced to use high polluting, low-cost cars; this limits their mobility during heat waves as cities are taking measures to address high levels of air pollution. It is also the poor who tend to live in housing with poor insulation and ventilation; not to mention limited access to green space, healthcare facilities and job opportunities to increase their income and afford more efficient homes and non-polluting cars.

Current policy responses to heat waves are limited to the Heat-Health-Warming alerts and the temporary ban of the use of polluting cars. The former has been effective in reducing deaths due to excessive temperatures in homes and healthcare facilities, while the latter has been effective in reducing, temporarily, the pollution levels in cities.

Similarly, as shown in the National Energy and Climate Plans submitted by member states to the European Commission, policies to alleviate energy poverty (in countries where they do exist) are limited to three areas: partial payment of energy bills; superficial renovation of buildings at a high public cost; and financial support for the use of public transport (if available) or for the replacement of inefficient vehicles.
The effectiveness of these policies is yet to be demonstrated given the continuous increase of EU citizens facing energy poverty.

Emergency response measures to address the consequences of heatwaves, despite their effectiveness in the short-term, are inadequate given the expected frequency and severity of heatwaves as reported by the IPCC SR 1.5.
A longer-term strategy is needed to adapt our infrastructures and buildings to the expected global warming and to tackle the causes of energy poverty. Unfortunately, National Energy and Climate plans submitted by member states to the European Commission fall short in addressing both heatwaves and energy poverty.

The transport and domestic energy poverty nexus hinders the right of European citizens’ access to energy and transport services—rights introduced by Principle 20 of the European Pillar of Social Rights- and heatwaves will only exacerbate the situation.

The new EU institutions have a mandate to make Europe’s energy transition a just transition. This can only be done if a European Marshall plan is implemented to fight climate change and to protect the vulnerable.

This Op-ed was published for the first time on July 1st , 2019 on Euractiv

Member States ranking and scoring in alleviating energy poverty
Country European Energy Poverty Index (EEPI) European Domestic Energy Poverty Index (EDEPI) European Transport Energy Poverty Index (ETEPI)
Rank Score Rank Score Rank Score
Sweden 1 86.34 1 95.41 7 78.13
Luxembourg 2 83.97 5 80.88 1 87.19
Austria 3 79.58 4 81.21 8 77.99
Denmark 4 78.94 3 81.88 13 76.10
Netherlands 5 77.25 8 78.09 12 76.42
France 6 75.35 10 73.33 11 77.43
United Kingdom 7 74.98 6 80.54 16 69.79
Belgium 8 73.26 11 64.62 5 79.37
Germany 9 72.32 9 75.77 18 69.02
Spain 10 71.80 12 64.67 4 79.72
Czech Republic 11 68.99 15 60.21 6 79.05
Poland 12 64.45 14 61.01 19 68.08
Romania 13 62.40 13 64.23 20 60.63
Cyprus 14 62.27 21 46.23 2 83.90
Slovenia 15 62.05 20 51.34 14 74.99
Lithuania 16 57.42 23 42.37 10 77.82
Croatia 17 57.19 16 58.79 21 55.64
Greece 18 56.70 22 43.69 15 73.58
Ireland 19 55.86 7 79.29 25 39.35
Portugal 20 53.42 25 36.67 9 77.83
Latvia 21 52.55 24 40.01 17 69.03
Italy 22 52.09 19 52.10 22 5.08
Estonia 23 48.65 18 58.02 23 40.80
Slovakia 24 26.33 26 8.35 3 83.04
Finland 25 18.38 2 85.56 27 3.95
Malta 26 15.56 17 58.56 26 4.13
Bulgaria 27 5.30 28 0.71 24 39.55
Hungary 28 4.57 27 6.19 28 3.38